VRS Hybrid Plan Pros and Cons
Pros and Cons for Plan 1 and Plan 2 Members
The VRS Hybrid Retirement Plan (Hybrid Plan) was created by the Virginia General Assembly as a way for the state to save money. As a result, Plan 1 and Plan 2 members may think their plans are better than the Hybrid Plan. However, it might be advantageous for some employees to opt-in to the Hybrid Plan. Following are some issues that Plan 1 and Plan 2 members may want to consider to determine if that is a good choice for them.
Pros
- Is health or longevity an issue? Plan 1 and Plan 2 will pay substantially all of their value in lifetime monthly benefits.
- Are you an expert investor? Be honest!
- Do you anticipate moving soon to another job that is not covered by VRS?
- Is flexibility more important than retirement income security?
Cons
- Is your health good?
- Are you a poor investor?
- Do you have roots in the area?
- Do you anticipant salary increases, either from promotion or inflation?
- Is retirement income security more important than flexibility?
This following chart summarizes the VRS plans that are are more advantageous for the above concerns.
Employee Concern or Goal |
Plan That is More Advantageous |
|
Family History of longevity and healthy lifestyle |
Plan 1-2 |
|
Investment acumen & willingness to spend time on investment |
|
Hybrid |
Health issues that shorten longevity |
|
Hybrid |
Keep it simple |
Plan 1-2 |
|
Portability – change jobs prior to normal retirement age |
|
Hybrid |
Preference of security of monthly income over a lump sum |
Plan 1-2 |
|
Preference for the flexibility of a lump sum over security |
|
Hybrid |
Pay raises late in career significantly boosting final average salary |
Plan 1-2 |
|
Discipline to consistently make maximum deductions for maximum match |
|
Hybrid |
Perseverance to stay employed until Normal Retirement Age |
Plan 1-2 |
|